Arizona’s Unusual Ice Cream Flavors (and Who’s Making Them)
Arizona takes ice cream seriously. When the heat never quits, dessert has to keep up. Across the state, local shops are making flavors that sound wrong but taste right. These five prove that weird ideas and desert creativity are a perfect mix.
1. Novel Ice Cream – Cookie Monster
📍 Phoenix, Arizona
Bright blue, cookie-stuffed, and unapologetically loud, Cookie Monster is a sugar rush that feels right at home in the desert. Novel is known for its donut ice cream sandwiches, but this flavor alone is enough reason to visit. It is messy, nostalgic, and completely over the top.
It should not be blue, yet it works. Somehow that makes it better.
2. Udder Delights – Dill Pickle
📍 Gilbert, Arizona
Udder Delights in Gilbert takes pride in using local ingredients and fearless ideas. Their Dill Pickle flavor starts salty and sour before giving way to a surprisingly creamy finish. It sounds like a dare but turns out to be a refreshing way to beat the heat.
It tastes exactly like a pickle. And somehow that is a good thing.
3. The Screamery – Drunkin’ Cowboy
📍 Tucson, Arizona
The Screamery has a reputation for rich, small-batch ice cream made from scratch. Drunkin’ Cowboy blends bourbon, roasted almonds, and chocolate flakes into something smoky and smooth. It tastes like a reward at the end of a long desert day.
A scoop with bourbon in it feels rebellious, which is exactly the point.
4. Timberline Ice Cream – Coconut Dragon
📍 Flagstaff, Arizona
Timberline’s Coconut Dragon combines creamy coconut with bright dragon fruit for a flavor that feels tropical in mountain country. It is bright, tangy, and completely out of place at 7,000 feet, which makes it unforgettable.
Coconut and dragon fruit belong on an island, not in Flagstaff. That is what makes it fun.
5. Oh Sweetie – Churro Cheesecake Ice Cream
📍 Williams, Arizona
Right off Route 66, Oh Sweetie serves its signature Churro Cheesecake Ice Cream made with homemade cheesecake ice cream, cinnamon sugar, and graham cracker crust. It tastes like the best parts of a state fair folded into a frozen dessert. The shop is only open on weekends, so plan your visit before you go.
It combines two full desserts in one scoop and somehow makes it work.
Why Arizona Does Ice Cream Differently
Arizona’s ice cream scene is not about perfection. It is about personality. Each of these shops proves that the desert rewards creativity and that weird flavors have their place right beside the classics. The next time you want to cool off, skip the safe choice. Order something strange.
In this state, weird always wins.
Subscribe to Roam Arizona
Sign up to get new Arizona stories, hidden gems, and updates delivered to your inbox.
You’re officially on the trail.
Peek at your inbox (or the spam gulch) for your first map.
